Cost of crisis intervention

The German government spent 50.4 billion euros on financial relief measures during the energy crisis triggered by Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The total expenditure was disclosed in a Federal Ministry of Finance response to a parliamentary inquiry by Green Party budget politician Sebastian Schäfer. The ministry listed 27 separate spending programs designed to lower heating and power expenses for consumers while stabilizing supply markets. The final bill was substantially smaller than the 200 billion euro borrowing authorization announced by Chancellor Olaf Scholz in September 2022 under his economic defense package.

Price caps and emergency payments

The single largest expenditure was the electricity price brake enacted in late 2022, which cost 16.3 billion euros. The program guaranteed households and small businesses an electricity price of 40 cents per kilowatt-hour for 80 percent of their prior consumption, while industrial clients had prices capped at 13 cents for 70 percent of their usage. The gas price brake accounted for 14.3 billion euros, providing households and small-to-medium enterprises a gross cap of 12 cents per kilowatt-hour for 80 percent of prior consumption, alongside a 9.5 cent cap for district heating. An initial emergency aid package in December 2022 cost 8.5 billion euros by covering a full month of heating advance payments for private households, small businesses, and social institutions.

Electricity price brake16.3

Gas price brake14.3

December 2022 emergency aid8.5

Electricity price brake

16.3 € billion

Gas price brake

14.3 € billion

December 2022 emergency aid

8.5 € billion

Data from the article text

Additional programs and excluded costs

Direct subsidies also included more than six billion euros for a 300-euro lump-sum payment distributed to pensioners across Germany. Smaller allocations funded heating subsidies for students, apprentices, and recipients of housing allowances, alongside support for energy-intensive companies. However, the ministry's 50.4 billion euro total excludes indirect costs such as tax reductions. Lowering the value-added tax on natural gas from 19 percent to seven percent between August 2022 and early 2024 reduced federal revenue by 3.3 billion euros and cost state and local governments nearly three billion euros. Factoring in the corporate rescue of gas importer Uniper and related stabilization measures, the Green Party calculates total government crisis expenditure at 71.7 billion euros.

Fiscal scrutiny and strategic dependence

The price brakes applied throughout 2023 and were initially extended through March 2024 by the Bundestag, but the federal cabinet rescinded the extension after a November 2023 Federal Constitutional Court ruling created an immediate deficit in the federal budget. Economists had previously criticized the universal subsidies for distributing funds broadly rather than targeting vulnerable households, while noting that cheaper gas weakened incentives to reduce consumption. Schäfer used the release of the spending figures to call for changes in long-term procurement strategy.

“We must never again enter into such one-sided and risky dependencies.”

Schäfer noted that decades of oil and gas imports had directed billions of euros to Moscow while eroding European security.

“A forward-looking budget policy must also keep in mind what financial, economic and security policy consequences a lack of precaution can cost us dearly tomorrow.”