We use analytics to improve Pollar and, with your consent, the Meta pixel to measure sign-ups and purchases that come from our ads. You can change this anytime in Settings. Privacy policy

Search⌘K
HomeFor YouLiveBriefAsk
MapMarketsThreadsSoundsFilms
DomesticGeopoliticsEconomySocietyScience & TechInfrastructureSportCultureLifestyle
Support PollarNotifications
PrivacyNewsroom
HomeBriefLiveThreadsSearch
Listen to the article4 min, read by a synthetic voice

In brief

  • An independent commission found City guilty of more than 100 breaches of Premier League financial rules between 2009 and 2018, with the Independent reporting 114 breaches.

  • The BBC cites more than £830m of disguised secret funding, the New York Times more than £850million and the Independent more than £900m.

  • Enzo Maresca said "Absolutely not" when asked whether City's achievements felt tainted, and said he would speak about the case when the appeal is won.

  • The New York Times says the current appeal could be wrapped up by the end of January 2027, with possible sanctions including points deductions and relegation.

ManchesterLondon
Manchester, Liverpool, London · United Kingdom
How it came to this
  1. International breakIndependent commission verdict announced
  2. 9 OctMaresca defends the club at his press conference ahead of the Anfield game
  3. 11 OctCity travel to Anfield to face Liverpool

The verdict and the appeal

An independent commission found Manchester City guilty of more than 100 breaches of Premier League financial rules covering 2009 to 2018. The count varies by outlet: the Independent reports 114 breaches, while Reuters and Al Jazeera use the wording "more than 100". Estimates of the disguised funding also differ, with the BBC citing more than £830m, the New York Times more than £850million and the Independent more than £900m. City deny all wrongdoing, have lodged an appeal and say the verdict contains "clear material errors of law, principle and fact". If the findings are upheld, Al Jazeera lists points deductions, fines, transfer embargoes and relegation as possible punishments. The New York Times says the current appeal could be concluded by the end of January 2027, while further appeals would almost certainly take years.

Maresca backs the titles

Enzo Maresca, who was part of Pep Guardiola's staff when City won the treble in 2022-23, rejected any suggestion that the club's titles were tainted at his press conference on Friday. Asked directly whether those achievements felt tainted, he replied "Absolutely not." He said he knew the effort put in by the players, the club and the manager during that season, and said he had no doubt about it. Maresca said he would "absolutely" still have taken the job had he known what lay ahead, and said the charges were never raised during his contract negotiations. Al Jazeera reports that he believes the appeal will be won.

“I trust the club because I trust the people. So that is why I joined the club.”

Enzo Maresca, manchester City manager

When reporters pressed him on whether he would stay regardless of sanctions, he turned the question back, asking "But what will we do if Manchester City win?" He declined to discuss the situation further until the appeal is decided.

“I would like to speak about this situation when we win the appeal.”

Enzo Maresca, manchester City manager

Managers react across the league

Mikel Arteta, who worked as Guardiola's assistant at City between 2016 and 2019, was asked at Arsenal's London Colney headquarters whether his conscience was clear. He answered "Yes" and then declined most follow-up questions, saying he wanted to respect the process and the timelines. Asked if he had spoken to Guardiola since the verdict, he said "I prefer not to answer those questions." He added that he believes the Premier League remains the best in the world, answering "100%" when asked.

“My position, and I think the club's position, is not to make any further comments until this is fully resolved.”

Mikel Arteta, arsenal manager and former Manchester City assistant to Pep Guardiola

Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola also addressed the case ahead of the weekend's fixture at Anfield. Manchester United manager Michael Carrick, a former United midfielder who finished second to City as both a player and assistant manager since the 2008 Abu Dhabi takeover, said speed is essential for everyone to be clear. City's chief executive Ferran Soriano called the verdict a "Premier League conspiracy theory" in a leaked video message to club staff.

“I think uncertainty is not good for anyone, and anyone involved, but the process is ongoing, and we have to be patient like everyone else and see what happens at the end.”

Andoni Iraola, liverpool manager

What comes next

Arsenal host Leeds at the Emirates Stadium on Saturday, three points behind City, who have won all five matches so far this season. City travel to Anfield on Sunday to face Liverpool, a club that has lost out to City often in recent seasons, and the New York Times expects the fixture to be one of the most watched Premier League games. Arteta will manage his first match since signing a contract extension with Arsenal until 2030, which he described as an honour in a statement quoted by the Independent. City's appeal remains ongoing, and no sanction has been applied while it is pending.

Next in today’s edition

Bend school shooting leaves three children and a teacher dead

A 16-year-old opened fire at Silver Rail Elementary in Bend, Oregon, on Thursday, 15 October, and a bystander shot the attacker inside the school, according to police and the bystander's family.

  • Government · 9 h agoZacharia reportedly out as White House press secretary
  • Diplomacy · 7 h agoPope Leo XIV asks Putin for Oleshky humanitarian truce
  • Business · 11 h agoTesla shows flying Roadster, production targeted for 2028

Sources and context

  • BBCon 9 Oct at 22:34Mikel Arteta: Arsenal boss has clear conscience over Man City charges
  • Irish Examineron 9 Oct at 22:31Arteta insists conscience is clear amid persistent City questions
  • The Independenton 9 Oct at 16:42What every Premier League manager said about the Man City verdict
  • Al Jazeera Onlineon 9 Oct at 16:28Premier League managers give first reaction to Man City crisis: All to know
Enzo Maresca
Manchester City manager who replaced Pep Guardiola in June
Mikel Arteta
Arsenal manager and former Manchester City assistant to Pep Guardiola
Pep Guardiola
Former Manchester City manager under whom Maresca and Arteta worked
Andoni Iraola
Liverpool manager
Michael Carrick
Manchester United manager and former United midfielder
Ferran Soriano
Manchester City chief executive who called the verdict a Premier League conspiracy theory

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar

First version on 8 Oct at 12:41, last change on 10 Oct at 00:51.

Report an error in the text

Text generated by AI from the reports of the publishers listed and checked automatically, with no human editor. How Pollar is made

In this text

The verdict and the appealThe verdict and the appealMaresca backs the titlesMaresca backs the titlesManagers react across the leagueManagers react across the leagueWhat comes nextWhat comes next

Based on reports by

BBC, Irish Examiner, The Independent, Al Jazeera Online, The New York Times, Reuters, ANSA.it

List of sources

Football · Manchester, Liverpool, and London

Maresca defends City's titles as the breach appeal against the 100-plus violation verdict goes on

Manchester City's manager says the club's trophies are not tainted and rejects any link between the appeal and his decision to join. Arsenal's Mikel Arteta and other Premier League managers were also asked about the verdict before league action resumes this weekend.

Manchester
Liverpool
London

Ask about this text

AI text based on reports by BBC, Irish Examiner, The Independent and other publishers. Changed on 10 Oct at 00:51.

Ask your own question
How it is made