Opinion columns argue that rigid rent caps tend to shrink supply and push the market informal, and that expropriating private homes does not fit a state governed by the rule of law.
A column cites a Banco de Portugal estimate of about 300,000 missing dwellings, with about 26,700 new homes completed in 2025 against 67,500 in 2007.
A column says the Espinho council under Miguel Reis and then Maria Manuel Cruz built no new homes under the PRR, and that a planned purchase of 150 dwellings never happened.
Maricarmen Abascal, 87, died on 7 October, after an eviction on 23 September that was broadcast live, and columnists read her case in opposite ways.
INE data cited show house prices up 16.5% in the second quarter of 2026 year on year, and the median rent on new contracts up 10.2%.
Demonstrators took to the streets of Porto on 16 October 2026 to protest the housing crisis, targeting rising prices, landlords, the government and the shortage of homes. Opinion columns published the same day disagree about what the protests mean and whether they offer workable answers. The head of the Porto academic federation, writing as a student leader, said colleagues are dropping out because they cannot pay for a room, and that the federation now offers 75 beds for students. He said he was worried by the protests and by images of a police intervention, while arguing that the demands largely reduce to rent caps and expropriations.
Several columns reject the two measures most often proposed by protesters. One argues that rigid rent caps have protected people who already have a home, but have reduced supply, degraded the housing stock and pushed the market informal, leaving younger people out. Another says expropriating private homes does not fit a state governed by the rule of law, because owners need legal certainty before they will invest, build or rent. A third column, focused on Porto, counts six demands on the protest list, four of them bans or caps, and says none proposes a solution on the supply side.
The figures cited come mainly from INE and the Banco de Portugal. INE data show house prices rose 16.5% in the second quarter of 2026 compared with a year earlier, while the median rent on new contracts rose 10.2%. The Banco de Portugal estimates the deficit at about 300,000 dwellings, according to one column. Completions reached about 26,700 new homes in 2025, the record year of the decade, against 67,500 in 2007, and more than 50,000 licensed dwellings from the last three years have not started, according to the APPII association.
Data from the article text
Another column cites a Eurostat figure of an increase of about 180% in Portuguese house prices between 2015 and 2025. The same piece notes that INE revised the resident population to 11.4 million in June 2026, about 640,000 above earlier estimates, which means plans sized for lower demand are falling behind. It also argues that if construction stayed at the highest pace of the last fifteen years, nearly nine in ten dwellings that will exist in 2056 already exist today.
A column on Espinho recounts that the winning candidate in the 2021 local election, Miguel Reis, presented himself as having privileged access to then prime minister António Costa, and that about 100 million euros for housing was discussed. Reis led the council for much of the PRR period, after which Maria Manuel Cruz took over. The author says the PRR deadline has ended and that the Espinho council built no new homes under the programme and did not complete a municipal construction contract on time. The planned purchase of 150 dwellings never materialised, and the column argues that applications, meetings and resolutions do not amount to homes.
Maricarmen Abascal, 87, had lived in Madrid since 1956 under an old-rent contract signed by her father. The building was sold to a fund, and the dispute dragged through the courts until an eviction on 23 September that was broadcast live. She died on 7 October, shortly after an agreement had been reached that would have allowed her to return home.
Columnists read the case in opposite ways. One argues that slow justice let the dispute run for years, while another says the left turned her case into a cause for renewing leases without end, pointing to two decrees bearing her name that were rejected in Congress.
One column links the Porto protests to unrest in France, Belgium, Italy, Spain and Albania, describing a shared ideological convergence. Its author argues that the political centre gave up liberal principles. Another column connects the protests to rising voter support for illiberal parties across Europe, which it attributes to living conditions and dissatisfaction with mainstream politics, especially among young people.
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support PollarHousing · Porto, Espinho, and Madrid
Demonstrators took to the streets of Porto on 16 October 2026 over the housing crisis, and Portuguese columnists disagreed on whether rent caps or new construction offer a way out.
AI text based on reports by Observador, PÚBLICO, Diário de Notícias and other publishers. Published .